Abracadabra NYC reviewProducts, prices, shipping and returns

What Abracadabra NYC sells

Abracadabra NYC sells costumes for adults, kids, teens, toddlers and babies, including sexy costumes, burlesque costumes, cosplay costumes, mascot suits, onesies and plus size costumes, with styles ranging from Disney, Star Wars, Marvel and DC to horror, historical decades, animals, couples and group costumes. The shop also carries cosplay and costume makeup, masks, wigs, glasses, weapons, holiday and party decorations, accessories, collectibles such as action figures, statues, pins, plush toys and bobbleheads, and gifts for men, women and kids, including goth gifts, skull gifts, funny gifts, games, puzzles, key chains, mugs, home decor, stationery, stickers and neon signs. The store offers costume and prop rentals, with prices starting at $100, most rentals priced between $125 and $200, and mascot costumes at $475 to rent.

Abracadabra NYC prices

Prices in Abracadabra NYC’s public product list run from $3.95 to $1,600, with a middle price of $65.95. Listed examples include a Chris Fehn signing and photo op ticket reservation at $10, a Frances plastic masquerade mask at $14.95, a Lisa Venetian mask at $14.95, a Giles metallic plastic Venetian mask at $16.95, a White Phantom plaster half mask at $16.95, a Patrizia diamond Venetian mask at $29.95, an Angelina laser cut metal mask at $32.95, a Fiora small Venetian mask at $24.95, a Fleur de Lis laser cut Venetian mask at $28.95, and the Eleanor, Titus and Godiva masks at $36.95. Costume rentals start at $100, most rentals are priced between $125 and $200, and the majority of mascot costumes are $475 to rent.

Abracadabra NYC shipping

Abracadabra NYC offers Ground, Expedited 2nd Day and Next Day shipping options within the USA, excluding weekends, with rates that vary depending on the items in the cart and the delivery address, and free shipping when a certain dollar threshold is met. All orders ship same day or the following business day, Monday through Friday excluding holidays, with a 2PM EST cutoff for same-day shipping. Most products can be shipped internationally, though prices do not reflect customs or duties. Abracadabra NYC also offers same-day local delivery for select areas in or near New York City and Wall, New Jersey, usually within 2 to 3 hours, with costs shown at checkout based on items and distance. Online orders can be picked up at the New York City store or the New Jersey warehouse, with most items ready within 24 hours.

Abracadabra NYC returns

Abracadabra NYC states that all transactions are final, with no refunds, returns or exchanges, for sanitary reasons and due to the nature of the items it sells. If an item arrives damaged or with missing parts, the buyer should leave it untouched and unused and contact the store within 48 hours with photos, and an exchange or refund may be granted. Approved refunds are applied to the original payment method. The store does not price match.

Good to know about Abracadabra NYC

Abracadabra NYC has operated since 1981 and is open year-round in New York City. The store provides seamstresses for custom jobs, makeup artists for hire and full decoration services for events, and it has served the entertainment industry with costumes, props and scenery for movies, television, music videos, theater and live events. A live master magician is present at the store on most days. Pickup orders are held for 30 days outside peak season, and during September, October and November orders not picked up within 72 hours are canceled with a 5% transaction fee. A typical costume rental lasts 3 days, with an option to extend for an additional fee, and throughout October rentals may be kept until one week after Halloween at no extra charge. Security deposits are collected at pickup, and late returns are charged 25% of the rental price per day. Contact lens orders require a digitally signed contact care sheet before fulfillment.

What was read

These pages of Abracadabra NYC’s own website, on 14 October 2026:

• Home page
• Shipping policy
• Returns policy
• About page
• Questions and answers
• Product list

This page sets out what Abracadabra NYC offers, from what it publishes about itself. No product was bought or tested.