Mystery Tackle Box reviewProducts, prices, shipping and returns

What Mystery Tackle Box sells

Mystery Tackle Box sells monthly subscription plans that deliver 4-10 baits per month, with the Regular Plan offering 4-6 baits, the Pro Plan 6-8 baits and the Elite Plan 8-10 baits. It also sells tackle kits such as the MTB USA Bass Kit, the MTB Fishmas Tackle Kit PRO, the MTB Bait Finesse System (BFS) Fishing Kit and the MTB Finesse Bass Fishing Kit. The range includes apparel — T-shirts, hoodies and hats — as well as accessories like bags and slings, gift cards, gift plans and holiday items such as the MTB 12 Days of Fishmas Advent Calendar.

Mystery Tackle Box prices

Mystery Tackle Box subscription plans start at $19.99 per month for the Regular Plan with 4-6 baits, $31.99 per month for the Pro Plan with 6-8 baits and $44.99 per month for the Elite Plan with 8-10 baits. Tackle kits on the site range from $29.99 for the MTB Fishmas Tackle Kit PRO to $89.99 for The Ultimate Fishing Tackle Kit. Apparel includes the MTB Elite Angler T-Shirt at $24.50 and the MTB:FC Longhorn Bass Hoodie at $39.50. The product list on the site covers prices from $4 to $189.99.

Mystery Tackle Box shipping

Mystery Tackle Box ships free on orders over $75. Gift subscriptions include free U.S. shipping, and the first gift box ships in 2 business days with delivery taking up to 7 business days. Standard gift delivery allows 5-7 business days. The site states that over 10 million boxes have been shipped.

Mystery Tackle Box returns

Mystery Tackle Box does not accept returns or exchanges. All sales are final for Mystery Tackle Boxes, specialty boxes, one-time products, apparel and other subscription boxes, and subscription boxes or any product received in the boxes are nonrefundable. The final day to cancel a subscription before being charged is the last day of the month, and once an order is processed it is ineligible for refunds or returns.

Discounts and offers at Mystery Tackle Box

Mystery Tackle Box states on its home page that it offers 15% off all plans during a sale period. It also offers a free G-Ratt Tackle Kit with select plans, valued at $55, and 20% off tackle kits during a promotion. Gift subscriptions include a 20% gift discount applied automatically in the cart. Gift plans are priced from $23.75 per box for the Regular size, $34.24 for the Pro size and $47.25 for the Elite size.

Good to know about Mystery Tackle Box

Each box contains hand-picked tackle with how-to-fish-it cards, and subscribers can choose their target species — bass, panfish and trout, inshore saltwater, multi-species or walleye — and switch species at any time. Subscribers can skip, swap species or cancel anytime. The site carries Trustpilot reviews with a 4.8 rating from over 12,840 verified reviews.

What was read

These pages of Mystery Tackle Box’s own website, on 16 October 2026:

• Home page
• Shipping policy
• Returns policy
• Questions and answers
• Product list

This page sets out what Mystery Tackle Box offers, from what it publishes about itself. No product was bought or tested.